BillCheck

Home / Resources / What is a freight audit, what does it find, and how do you run one?

What is a freight audit, what does it find, and how do you run one?

Published on November 6, 2026, updated on November 10, 2026 · The BillCheck team · 8 min read

A freight audit is the line by line check of every carrier invoice against what you agreed to pay: the contract rate and discount, the fuel table, the accessorial schedule, and what the bill of lading and the delivery receipt say actually happened. Done before payment, it stops overcharges. Done after, it recovers them. On most audits we run, the errors add up to 1 to 3% of the billed amount, sometimes 4.

What is a freight audit?

A freight audit compares each freight bill with three references: the rate agreement in force on the ship date, the shipping documents (bill of lading, weight and dimensions), and the delivery record (proof of delivery, time stamps). Every line that does not match is disputed with the carrier. A pre-payment audit runs before the invoice is paid. A post-payment audit, or post audit, reviews invoices already paid and claims refunds.

The idea is old. Shippers have paid outside firms to recheck freight bills for decades, usually on a share of what they recover. What changed is the volume. A shipper moving a few hundred LTL shipments a month gets a few hundred freight bills, each with its own linehaul, discount, fuel line and accessorials. Nobody in accounts payable checks all of that by hand. So the invoice gets approved if the total looks normal, and the small errors go through.

A freight bill audit works at the level of the line, not the total. Concretely: is the class on the bill the class on the BOL? Is the discount the one in the contract, or last year's? Is the fuel surcharge read from the right DOE week? Was the liftgate actually used? Each question has a document that answers it. The audit is the discipline of asking every question on every bill.

Two kinds of audit, then. Pre-payment is the better one: you never pay the wrong amount, and you never have to chase a refund. Post-payment still has its place, for the backlog, for a carrier you never checked, or to measure the problem before you change your process. In LTL, both start with the same thing: an LTL invoice audit against your tariff and your discount.

What does a freight audit find?

Most findings fall into seven families: the wrong rate or discount, the fuel surcharge computed on the wrong week or base, accessorials billed without a trigger, a weight or class changed after pickup, duplicate bills for the same shipment, wrong mileage on truckload lanes, and charges billed to the wrong party. At one manufacturing customer, we found about $9,700 of overcharges on 46 invoices from a single road carrier.

None of these are exotic. They come from how carrier billing works. Rates live in the carrier's system, and your contract terms have to be keyed in correctly and renewed on time. Fuel tables move every week. Accessorials are often added from the driver's handheld, sometimes by default. And a reclass after a dock inspection changes the linehaul, the fuel line and sometimes adds an inspection fee, all on one shipment.

Here is what each family looks like on an invoice:

  • Rate and discount: the discount applied is 68% when the contract says 72%, or the absolute minimum charge is the tariff's, not yours.
  • Fuel: the right percentage applied to the gross rate instead of the net, or the band of the invoice week instead of the ship week.
  • Accessorials: residential or limited access billed on a commercial address with a dock, a liftgate nobody asked for, detention without arrival and departure times, a lumper charge with no receipt. Our guide to accessorials lists the proof for each one, and the one on lumper fees shows what the receipt must match.
  • Weight and class: a reweigh or a reclass with no inspection certificate, or a parcel billed on dimensional weight with the wrong divisor.
  • Duplicates: the same PRO number billed twice, or once on the carrier's invoice and once through a broker.
  • Mileage: truckload miles from a different routing guide than the one in the contract.
  • Wrong party or terms: a collect shipment billed to you as prepaid, or a third party bill sent to the shipper.

How long do you have to dispute a freight bill?

For interstate motor carriers, federal law gives the shipper 180 days from receipt of a bill to contest it (49 U.S.C. 13710), and 18 months from delivery to sue to recover an overcharge (49 U.S.C. 14705). The carrier has 180 days from the original bill to issue a supplemental bill for extra charges. A written contract can change some of these rights, so read yours first.

These deadlines are why timing matters in a freight audit. A post-payment audit that looks back two years will find errors it can no longer claim. The 180-day window is the practical one: contest the bill in writing within 180 days of receiving it, and keep proof of the date. The same clock binds the carrier: after 180 days from the original bill, it loses the right to collect charges it forgot to bill, such as a reclass found late.

The table below sums up the federal clock for a for-hire motor carrier shipment. It is the default. Under 49 U.S.C. 14101(b), a shipper and a carrier can expressly waive rights and remedies in a written contract, and many contracts set their own claim and dispute periods. The contract you signed is the first document to read.

One more point on the credit period. Federal rules give a motor carrier 7 days to present its bill and, unless its tariff says otherwise, give you 15 days to pay it. A tariff can stretch that to 30 calendar days, no more. If the carrier sends a late payment charge, check the dates against its tariff before you pay it.

The federal clock on a motor carrier freight bill (interstate, for-hire), unless a written contract waives or changes it

StepDeadlineRuns fromSource
Carrier presents the freight bill7 days, weekends and holidays excludedPickup (prepaid) or delivery (collect)49 CFR 377.205
Shipper pays (credit period)15 days by default, up to 30 calendar days by tariffThe day after the bill is presented49 CFR 377.203
Carrier bills extra charges180 daysReceipt of the original bill49 U.S.C. 13710(a)(3)(A)
Shipper contests a bill180 daysReceipt of the bill49 U.S.C. 13710(a)(3)(B)
Shipper sues to recover an overcharge18 monthsDelivery or tender of delivery49 U.S.C. 14705(b) and (g)
Carrier sues to collect its charges18 monthsDelivery or tender of delivery49 U.S.C. 14705(a) and (g)
Shipper files a loss or damage claimAt least 9 months (the carrier cannot set less)Set by the carrier's rules or the contract49 U.S.C. 14706(e)

How do you run a freight audit, step by step?

Start with the references, not the invoices: the signed rate agreement, the fuel table, the accessorial schedule and the routing guide, each with its effective dates. Then match every bill to its shipment record, recompute each line, flag what differs beyond a set tolerance, and dispute it in writing within 180 days. Track what the carrier credits, because a dispute that is never followed up is a refund you never get.

The order matters. Most failed audits fail at step one: the person checking the bill does not have the current contract, or has a PDF with three amendments missing. Gather the rate terms and their effective dates first. Then pull the shipment data: BOL weight and class, dimensions, pickup and delivery times, the accessorials actually requested.

Set a tolerance before you start. A one cent rounding gap is not worth a dispute. A discount off by four points is. Typically, shippers set a small absolute amount per line and dispute everything above it. Then group the disputes by carrier and send them together, with the evidence attached for each line: the contract clause, the BOL, the delivery receipt.

Last step, the one most often skipped: close the loop. Check that each credit arrives on the next statement and is not netted against a new charge. And feed the findings back. If the same error shows up every month, the fix is in the carrier's system, not in your audit.

  1. 1

    References

    Rate agreement, discount, fuel table, accessorial schedule, routing guide, each with its effective dates.

  2. 2

    Match

    Tie every bill to its shipment: PRO number, BOL, weight, class, dimensions, delivery record.

  3. 3

    Recompute

    Linehaul, discount, minimum, fuel on the right base and week, each accessorial against its trigger.

  4. 4

    Dispute

    Every gap above your tolerance, in writing, within 180 days of receiving the bill, with the evidence.

  5. 5

    Close the loop

    Check the credits on the next statement, then fix the recurring errors at the source.

Freight audit software, a service or freight auditors: which one do you need?

It depends on what you lack. Software checks every bill against rules you maintain, so you need someone who keeps the contract terms up to date. A freight audit and payment provider also pays the carriers for you, which changes your cash flow and your controls. Independent freight auditors usually work on post-payment recovery and are paid on what they recover. Many shippers combine a pre-payment check with a periodic post audit.

Freight audit and payment, often shortened to FAP, bundles two jobs. The provider receives the carrier invoices, audits them, then pays the carriers from funds you send it, and you get one consolidated bill. It saves accounts payable a lot of work. It also puts a third party between you and your carriers' money, so check how funds are held, how fast carriers are paid, and who owns the data.

Whatever you pick, ask the same four questions. Does it check every line, or only invoices above a threshold? Does it read your actual contract terms, including amendments, or a simplified rate table? Does it handle the documents you have, including PDFs and scanned delivery receipts? And who sends the disputes and follows the credits? A tool that flags errors nobody disputes saves nothing.

That is the part BillCheck takes on: every line of every invoice checked against your contract, with the evidence for each gap, for truckload, LTL and freight forwarder invoice audits. On one batch of 7 invoices, the gaps came to 10.6% of the billed amount. That is not the norm. It is what a contract term keyed in wrong does over a few months.

Run a freight audit on carrier invoices

  1. Gather the rate agreement, discount, fuel table, accessorial schedule and routing guide, with their effective dates
  2. Match every freight bill to its shipment: PRO number, bill of lading, weight, class, dimensions and delivery record
  3. Recompute each line: linehaul, discount, minimum charge, fuel on the right base and week, each accessorial against its trigger
  4. Dispute every gap above your tolerance in writing within 180 days of receiving the bill, with the evidence attached
  5. Check the credits on the next statement and fix recurring errors at the source

Frequently asked questions

What does a freight auditor do?

A freight auditor checks carrier invoices against the shipper's contract and shipping records, line by line: rate, discount, fuel surcharge, accessorials, weight, class, mileage and duplicates. Each error is disputed with the carrier, with the contract clause and the shipment documents as evidence. Independent freight auditors mostly work after payment and are usually paid a share of what they recover for the shipper.

What does freight audit and payment mean?

Freight audit and payment means one provider both audits your carrier invoices and pays the carriers on your behalf. You fund an account, the provider checks each bill, pays the approved amount and sends you a consolidated statement with the disputed lines. It reduces work in accounts payable. It also means a third party handles your freight money, so check how funds are held and how disputes are reported.

How long do you have to dispute a freight bill?

For an interstate shipment with a motor carrier, 49 U.S.C. 13710 gives the shipper 180 days from receipt of the bill to contest it. To sue to recover an overcharge, 49 U.S.C. 14705 gives 18 months from delivery. A written transportation contract can waive or change these rights, and many set their own dispute periods, so check yours before you plan a look back audit.

Is a freight bill the same as a bill of lading?

No. The bill of lading is the shipping document issued at pickup: shipper, consignee, pieces, weight, class, special instructions. The freight bill is the carrier's invoice for the move. In a freight audit, the bill of lading is one of the references: the weight, class and accessorials on the freight bill should match what the bill of lading shows, unless the carrier documents a change.

How are freight audits priced?

Three models are common. Post-payment recovery firms usually take a share of what they recover, so you pay nothing if they find nothing. Software and pre-payment services usually charge per invoice, per shipment or a monthly fee. Freight audit and payment providers often combine a per invoice fee with payment processing. Compare them on what they actually check and who handles the disputes, not only on the price.

Sources

Read next

Get your freight bills audited

  1. 1Send us three invoices and your rate sheet
  2. 2We show you the overcharges live, during the demo
Book a demo

You leave with the discrepancy report, whether you work with us afterwards or not.